It’s an interesting debate and one that could rumble on and on without ever getting a definitive answer but are Wigan Athletic better off in the Championship than we are in a league where we’ve reached our peak and can progress little further?
Well we certainly wouldn’t be better off financially, that goes without saying. However, most football fans attend on a Saturday afternoon in the hope of seeing their beloved team pick up three points and then go out to celebrate afterwards. All latics fans seem to do these days is go out sulking and dissecting another defeat and contemplating the thought of relegation for the first time in nearly two decades.
The question is, what good is it doing the club getting beat seemingly every weekend and struggling to stay in the division when we could be a division lower, being a bigger fish in a much smaller pond and finding wins easier to come by? It doesn’t necessarily work like that though, as the likes of Charlton, Southampton, Leeds, Sheffield Wednesday, Sheffield United and Bradford City would be quick to remind you (Blimey, they like relegation cake in Yorkshire!!)
Being relegated brings with it its own problems, not least the huge drop in TV revenue. Squads get ripped apart by clubs in the division you’ve just departed, who eye up your best assets. Crowds also drop as it becomes harder to attract fans to games against Doncaster and Barnsley (I’ve got it in for Yorkshire today!) than it does Manchester United and Liverpool .
The club is in a sound position financially and I dare say if we did suffer relegation we’d arguably be in a healthier state than any club ever to have been relegated from the Premier League in its 20-year history. Again though, that doesn’t guarantee that all in the garden will be rosy.
The hope would be that the club would have a season to rival that amazing one in 2004-05 where everyone is brushed aside with relative ease and those Saturday post-match trips to the pub would be upbeat affairs contemplating the thought of promotion to the top division back among England’s elite! Hang on – we’ve been there and didn’t like it!
It’s very difficult to decide between Premier League or Championship and ultimately it’s all a matter of personal opinion and what you’d rather see on a Saturday afternoon. I don’t think anyone would rather see us welcoming Doncaster to the DW on a Saturday afternoon than Manchester United, although I guess some would simply to avoid the usual four or five-goal trouncing we usually suffer against United.
It’s fair to say that the Premier League has changed massively since our arrival seven years ago. The prime example is Manchester City . For years we were their bogey team and regularly went to Eastlands and surprised a few. In comes a wealthy sheikh with a gigantic pot of cash and suddenly trips to Eastlands are all about keeping the score down. I, for one, refused to go to Eastlands this season for this very reason. It’s just not football and is not what football should be about.
If you look at the crowds issue at the DW (is that a can of worms you can hear opening?) that’s another problem we’d be presented with should we suffer the dreaded ‘R’ word. Being in the best league in the World should make it easier to attract fans and therefore the fan base should grow faster the longer we stay in the top flight. Relegation would make it tougher. Season tickets would be harder to sell and the cost would probably go up into the bargain, due to the loss in TV revenue. Plus I’m not even sure you’d be able to give tickets away for Wigan v Doncaster (I think I’d better stay away from that part of the country for a while!)
That last paragraph probably sounds a bit far fetched and arrogant when you consider Doncaster are a club of similar size to Wigan Athletic and have had a similar rise up through the leagues to us over the last decade or so. But the simple fact is our regular fans and those that come when they feel like it have got a little used to see English football’s elite turn up at the DW these days, so it goes without saying that we’ll suffer in that respect.
It’s my personal view that we’re better off where we are. Yes we get some tonkings and some inept performances in the Premier League, but the same is possible a league below, just a bit less often.
Something else I’ll say about the Premier League (and it’s something I’ve never experienced before promotion in 2004) is that every goal you score and every point you pick up matters ten-fold. Some of the celebrations in the Premier League days at the DW have been quite incredible, last season against W*st H*m being easily the best.
What would happen in the Championship? Lots of ‘home bankers’ where we’re expecting to turn a side over. We score, everyone gets up with a quick “yay well done lads” and sits back down on their hands. Whereas in the Premier League we’ve got our friends from Horwich coming up in a couple of weeks and I know for a fact any goal scored against that lot will be celebrated properly!! That’s the kind of experience I want.
Ultimately what we’ve got to remember is that the club is being run properly. People seem to want us to go out and spend millions to try and compete with the very best. Well I’m sorry but it just doesn’t work like that any more and you’ve only got to look at the likes of Sunderland to see where that can get you.
Now correct me if I’m wrong but I know what club I’d rather be supporting. If Ellis Short decided to leave Sunderland tomorrow that club would descend into chaos, and the same could be said for the likes of Chelsea and Manchester City too. Latics, meanwhile, are in such a healthy position nowadays that if Dave Whelan were to depart, there would still be a Wigan Athletic and it would still be a club run in the way all football clubs should be run.
For fans moaning post-Aston Villa that we’re not good enough etc (I was one at the time, mind you!) a reality check is needed. This isn’t a league about who is the best football club with the best footballers, it’s a league about who has the wealthiest owner and can spend the largest amounts of cash. Sunderland have proven to those without a billionaire owner that there's simply no point trying to compete with the big boys. It's better to try and survive by spending what you've got coming in and no more.
I wanted us to go to Aston Villa yesterday and win as much as the rest did. We lost because we didn’t play well rather than anything else, but ultimately we have to be realistic and say that our next fixture against B**ton is the one with everything to play for. In fact I’d say our next six fixtures, which are all winnable, are the ones that we should be looking forward to as Wigan fans and ones where we can accurately asses how well (or otherwise) we’re doing on the pitch.
I haven’t answered the question from my opening paragraph because it’s simply a matter of opinion as to which league we’re better off in. Me personally, I’m happy seeing us defying the odds season after season and showing that you don’t have to spend tens of millions of pounds just to survive among the big boys. Games like the one against Villa happen and people need to realise that, get on with it and then look forward to the next game.
When all is said and done I’d rather have it the way we’ve got it because I know full well that no matter what ridiculous amounts of money other clubs are spending just to try and keep up with the big guns, we’ll carry on doing things our way, which is the way it should be done.
There will always be a Wigan Athletic.